Head-to-Head: New York City FC vs St. Louis City

New York City FC and St. Louis City have met 4 times between 15 February 2023 and 4 April 2026. New York City FC have won 0, St. Louis City have won 2, and 2 meetings ended level, with New York City FC scoring 5 goals to St. Louis City’s 9. The latest meeting was New York City FC 1–1 St. Louis City on 4 April 2026 in Major League Soccer. The previous meeting was St. Louis City 3–1 New York City FC on 12 February 2025 in Friendlies Clubs.

Past matches, New York City FC vs St. Louis City

4 April 2026 Regular Season - 6

New York City FC

1 - 1

St. Louis City
12 February 2025 Club Friendlies 5

St. Louis City

3 - 1

New York City FC
3 March 2024 Regular Season - 3

St. Louis City

2 - 0

New York City FC

CITYPARK
15 February 2023 Club Friendlies 3

New York City FC

3 - 3

St. Louis City

Match center

New York City FC

1 - 1

4 April 2026

St. Louis City

Starting eleven

Substitutes New York City FC

32
M
34
D
11
F
2
D
99
F
87
F
30
G
19
D
29
M

St. Louis City Substitutes

M
28
D
5
F
36
F
80
M
59
D
4
F
77
D
14
G
39

Match events

45'

90'

⚽

⇄

⚽

43'

D. Edelman Yellow Card
44'

C. Durkin Yellow Card
50'
⚽

H. Wolf Normal Goal (Asst: M. Moralez)
56'

J. Orozco Yellow Card
58'

H. Wolf Yellow Card
61'

D. Polvara Yellow Card
65'

M. Perez C. Durkin
71'

L. MacNaughton D. Edelman
71'

C. Teuchert S. Cordova
75'

J. Shore K. Parks
75'

Raul Gustavo T. Gray
80'

M. Joyner Rafael Santos
80'

B. McSorley S. Becher
87'

Talles Magno A. Ojeda
88'

N. Cavallo A. O'Neill
90' +5
⚽

B. McSorley Normal Goal (Asst: L. MacNaughton)

Stats for this game

Matchup New York City FC VS St. Louis City

St. Louis City lead the recorded series

Across 4 completed meetings from 15 February 2023 to 4 April 2026, New York City FC have won 0, St. Louis City have won 2, and 2 draws are recorded. The aggregate score is 5–9 from New York City FC’s perspective. St. Louis City lead the recorded series. This is a historical sample of completed fixtures, not a statement about current form or a future result.

Recent results and scope

Recent results were 4 April 2026, New York City FC 1–1 St. Louis City at New York City FC in Major League Soccer; 12 February 2025, St. Louis City 3–1 New York City FC at St. Louis City in Friendlies Clubs; 3 March 2024, St. Louis City 2–0 New York City FC at St. Louis City in Major League Soccer. Home teams won 2 matches and away teams won 0 matches, while 2 draws were recorded. Every cited score is taken from the completed fixture record, and no broader claim is implied. The record is limited to these listed meetings and says nothing about unlisted fixtures, current strength, or future results.